Skip to content

Southern

Buttermilk Pie

A custard pie of buttermilk, sugar, and egg. It sets as it cools. Do not cut it hot.

Prep
15 min
Cook
45 min
Total
1 hr
Servings
4
Difficulty
Easy
Jump to recipe
Buttermilk Pie on a plate, finished and ready to eat, no text

Photo: Kimberly Vardeman (CC BY 2.0). Source

Why you’ll love it

  • Buttermilk Pie is seasoned before it cooks so the salt is in the food, not just on top
  • A wide pan or pot keeps the food from steaming in a pile
  • The eggs is there for the flavor people expect from this dish
  • The a pinch of nutmeg goes on at the end so it stays bright

Ingredients

Servings4

Ingredient amounts scale. Oven temperature and cook time do not. Salt, spices, and leaveners are a starting point after you scale. Taste and adjust.

View list

Check the ingredients you still need, then add them. If nothing is checked, the full list is added. Saved on this device.

Instructions

  1. 1

    Heat the oven to 350°F. Butter or line the pan you are using.

  2. 2

    Stir the unbaked pie crust with the eggs, buttermilk, butter, flour, vanilla until the batter or filling is smooth.

  3. 3

    Fold in the s sugar.

  4. 4

    Spread it in the pan and bake 45 minutes, until a toothpick comes out clean or the center is just set.

  5. 5

    Cool on a rack. Hot fillings need at least 20 minutes or they will not slice.

  6. 6

    Finish with the a pinch of nutmeg and serve. Cook until the eggs are set and firm.

Pro tips

  • Read the list and set everything out before the pan is hot
  • If the pan starts to smoke, lower the heat instead of adding a flood of liquid
  • Leftovers taste better reheated in a skillet than in a cold microwave pile

Easy substitutions

eggs
a close spice or sauce you already cook with
a pinch of nutmeg
chopped herbs you have

Storage and reheating

Storage

Refrigerate leftovers in a sealed container for up to 3 days.

Reheating

Reheat in a skillet or the microwave until hot all the way through.

Nutrition

Estimates per serving, using standard ingredient averages and rounded to the nearest gram. This is not a lab analysis, and it shifts if you change brands or add sides.

Calories
306
Protein
5 g
Carbs
40 g
Fat
14 g
Fiber
0 g

Budget friendly · Oven

You might also like

Banana Bread

Ripe bananas, butter, sugar, egg, and baking soda bake into one loaf. It is done when a toothpick in the center comes out with a few moist crumbs, not wet batter.

1 hr 15 min · Easy

View recipe

Chocolate Layer Cake

A two-layer cocoa cake mixed with hot coffee, then filled and covered with chocolate buttercream. The coffee does not make it taste like coffee. It makes the chocolate louder.

1 hr · Medium

View recipe

Red Velvet Cake

A cocoa-kissed red velvet layer cake with a tangy cream cheese frosting. The layers bake until the centers are fully set before they are stacked.

1 hr 2 min · Medium

View recipe

Atlantic Beach Pie

Atlantic Beach Pie is a searched plate. Bake it until the center is set and the top is browned. This is Atlantic Beach Pie for four, with written amounts.

55 min · Easy

View recipe

Still hungry?

More in the same lane, not a random mix.

Cola Cake

Cola Cake is a searched plate. Bake it until the center is set and the top is browned. This is Cola Cake for four, with written amounts.

55 min · Easy

View recipe

Derby Pie

Derby Pie is a searched plate. Bake it until the center is set and the top is browned. This is Derby Pie for four, with written amounts.

55 min · Easy

View recipe

Mississippi Mud Pie

Mississippi Mud Pie is a searched plate. Bake it until the center is set and the top is browned. This is Mississippi Mud Pie for four, with written amounts.

55 min · Easy

View recipe

From the kitchen

Kitchen tools we love

Practical tools these recipes actually use. This is not a review roundup, and these are not paid placements. If affiliate links are added later, they will be labeled and disclosed.

  • A heavy 12-inch skillet

    Most of the chicken and steak recipes are written for one pan that holds heat. Stainless or cast iron both work.

  • An air fryer with a real basket

    The air-fryer recipes expect a single layer. A crowded basket steams instead of browning.

  • A half-sheet pan

    Drumsticks, potatoes, sausage, and carrots all use one. A dark pan browns faster than a very shiny one.

  • A sharp chef’s knife

    These recipes do not need a specialty blade. A sharp 8-inch knife is faster and safer than a dull one.

  • A large cutting board

    Big enough that the onion and the raw chicken are not sharing the same puddle.

  • Dry cups and a liquid cup

    Desserts in particular expect level dry measures and a separate cup for milk.

  • An instant-read thermometer

    Use it for poultry, pork chops, and meatloaf. Color is a weak guide.

Read the affiliate disclosure.

Ingredients